Is NBR prepared to take on the challenge of increased tax net?

For the upcoming fiscal year (FY23), the National Board of Revenue (NBR) has not only been given the target of collecting more taxes but it will also have to face a big challenge as a result of the massive increase in tax net.

The revenue board needs to strengthen its service centers to support the taxpayers as millions of new taxpayers would be compelled to submit tax returns in the upcoming fiscal year if the proposed measures are approved in the Finance Act 2022 this week, experts suggest.

Regarding the matter, former chairman of the National Board of Revenue (NBR), Dr Muhammad Abdul Mazid told the Dhaka Tribune: “It seems that it will be challenging for the NBR to meet its revenue target for FY23. One of the main reasons for this is that earlier NBR officials used to set targets considering their own capabilities. As a result, they were very close to achieving the target but now a goal is set from the top which may not match the reality on the ground.”

“As a result, the deficit continues to grow and even in FY23, the revenue target has been set at 12% more than last year. At the end of the current fiscal year, there will be a revenue deficit of around Tk35-40 thousand crore more than the target.”

AB Mirza Azizul Islam, economist and financial adviser to a caretaker government earlier said: “Although the target of the proposed budget for FY23 is acceptable, implementation will be difficult as there will be many challenges. In addition, as the pressure on NBR to collect large sums of revenue increases, so will the pressure on the people.”

How can the NBR cope with the new target?

The former NBR chief Abdul Mazid said: “There have been talks about automation for a long time. In some places, they have even implemented it, which is certainly promising. 

“But the NBR's online services need to be enhanced further to meet this wide target challenge. Again, not only is there a shortage of workers but there is also a shortage of skilled or technically updated staff. Above all, the NBR needs to change the way they work.”

“In this year's budget, various steps have been taken to bring the people of upazilas or the thanas under the tax net. Surprisingly, the government has nine different spending offices like the Department of Social Welfare Office, but still in all the upazilas there are no income tax offices.”

To remedy this, this former head of the NBR suggested the government invest more money and support in the NBR.

“The government has to think differently about the revenue office modernization and the facilities of its staff, as they are the ones who bring money to run the state. 

“In 2008, when I was in charge, I allocated Tk140 crore for the construction of the NBR building in Agargaon. Today, even after a decade, it has not happened.”

“Simply put, the way the revenue sector has been increased in this year's budget is unimaginable considering its capacity,” he added.

The new notable tax sectors in this year's budget

In order for any business to get tax benefits, all types of receipts and income have to be done through bank accounts. 

More than Tk12 lakh has to be spent and invested through bank transfer. In other words, if the company makes a cash transaction of more than Tk12 lakh, that company will not be eligible to get the benefit of tax exemption.

It will have to pay corporate tax at the previous rate. This condition applies to everyone, whether the company is big or small.

In the budget, the finance minister has announced the same tax rate for all export-oriented industries (12% for general industries and 10% for green industries), which has been praised in various quarters. But Certainly, this facility will further increase the responsibilities and workload of the NBR.

Meanwhile, the tax at the source of export has been increased from 0.5% to 1%, meaning, the tax at the source of export has been doubled. 

According to data, 62% to 65% of the tax collected by the income tax department every year comes from source tax. During FY21, about Tk51,000 crore has been collected from tax deducted at source (TDS). 

In the proposed budget, a provision has been made to penalize companies for the failure to deduct and collect tax at source. 

If an organization deducts tax at source at a lower rate than set, a provision has been made to collect the tax from the organization itself for the amount of tax deducted less. 

The income tax department can also impose a maximum fine of Tk10 lakh for this failure. 

On top of that, the power of tax officials has been increased in the budget to speed up tax collection activities at source. 

In case of suspicion, tax officials now can enter any business organization without any prior permission. In this case, if they face any obstacle, they will be able to impose a fine of up to Tk50 lakh on the company. 

Apart from this, all kinds of industry owners, big and small, are now under the tax net. For example, in the budget, besides the issue of certificate (notice of tax collection), a provision has been added to disconnect gas-electricity-water for failing to pay tax. As a result, now the Income NBRs Tax Department will be able to send notices to the concerned service providers. 

The service provider must take action within 21 days of receiving the notice, otherwise, action will be taken against the service provider in accordance with the Income Tax Act.

A provision has been made to recover the arrears of tax from the directors of the company which has been closed for more than three years due to losses.

Besides, another provision has been made, the government has proposed an income tax on waived interest against default loans disbursed by banks and financial institutions in the budget for the fiscal year 2022-23.

At present, excise duty on bank deposits of five crore taka is Tk 40,000. But according to the finance ministers' proposed budget for FY23, this excise duty will increase by another Tk10,000. Excise duty of Tk50,000 will be deducted at any time of the next fiscal year if the amount of money as a bank touches Tk5 crore.

From July 1, it has been made mandatory to hang the Tax Return deposit slip instead of TIN (Taxpayer Identification Number) at the place of business or shop. In case of deviation, a minimum fine of Tk5,000 and a maximum fine of Tk20,000 will have to be paid.

All this means that it will not be so surprising if the pressure to file tax returns increases suddenly.

NBR’s target for the upcoming fiscal year is Tk3,70,000 crore, an increase of Tk40,000 crore from last year.