OP-ED: Is capitalism bad for the environment?

Ecologists and environmentalists often blame the over extraction of natural resources due to overpopulation as the main culprit of environmental problems.

However, they fail to recognize how capitalism plays a role in causing environmental problems.

And here’s why

Capitalism is an economic system in which profit-maximization motive forms the heart or core of the system and regards rising growth and productivity rates as the virtues of the system.

This profit-maximization principle, on one hand, drives producers to specialize in whatever they produce and invest in the latest and more efficient technologies to cut down costs.

On the other hand, it causes producers to try to increase productivity and scale up profits and also allocate resources in a way that boosts growth and dynamism.

As the system creates a highly competitive environment, producers are always trying to lower their costs to stay in the market and compete with their competitors.

This in turn compels them to invest in cost-cutting technologies to remain in the market and compete.

Together, a virtuous cycle of efficiency, productivity and profit optimization is created.

So, if capitalism is so virtuous, why is it being blamed for causing environmental issues?

Even though capitalism may seem like a system which creates a virtuous cycle, it also leads to the creation of a vicious cycle that affects the environment.

Capitalism is fueled by endless growth of production at the cost of natural resource depletion, pollution and climate change.

Moreover, production itself is dependent on consumption, which in turn creates demand for production.

So, without consumption, production will cease to exist.

This is precisely why capitalism promotes consumerism, which in turn is happening at the cost of the environment and depletion of natural resources.

Also, by over-extracting natural resources, capitalism is not willing to acknowledge the fact that the Earth is a finite planet with limited resources which are bound to be depleted in a capitalist economy.

The next section analyses the dynamics of the capitalist system and three propositions that make this system hazardous for the environment:

Dynamics of the capitalist system

First, in a capitalist economy firms are subject to enormous competition which forces them to try to cut costs to compete with their competitors and stay in the market.

This deliberate attempt to cut down costs by all the firms causes some of the costs to be projected onto the environment as proposed by Eric Wright, an economic sociologist at the University of Wisconsin-Madison.

For example, in Bangladesh factories directly dump their wastes into rivers instead of treating the waste partially which would contribute to increase in costs.

This behaviour is evident around the globe because the market dynamics in capitalism does not entail measures to prevent this behavior.

Hence, forcing corrective action requires the involvement of non-market forces such as the state or other social organizations.

Even states show reluctance to take measures. Sometimes, influential social activists and organizations can pressurize the state to take responsibility and action.

The second argument is that non-renewable natural resources are underpriced under capitalism, with no regard for the future, which causes them to be subject to over-extraction.

The sharp increase in the rate of greenhouse gas emissions since the 1990s, driven by strong economic growth in developing countries strengthens the argument.

China and India happen to be examples of economies that have grown immensely in the past two decades by using their non-renewable natural resources and thereby being big emitters of carbon gas.

This is also partly due to the fact that non-renewable resources are underpriced in a capitalist system as their future value is not accounted for.

So, what can be done?

Since the capitalist system does not provide measures or mechanisms to tackle these environmental issues, non-market interventions in the form of government interventions and interventions by other social groups may become necessary to tackle the environmental problems.

Some may argue that the state should take responsibility and heavily tax the ones who cause damage to the environment.

But often it becomes impossible for states to do so because they are backed by the influential business class and has to give these business groups incentives in return so that they keep the economy running and ensure economic growth and create job opportunities.

So, often states are reluctant to take measures against business-groups as it would hamper the relations between them.

For example, the Chinese and Indian governments pay no heed to the damages the huge industries cause to the environment in their countries.

The same applies to small firms who are reluctant to reduce environmental damage, because they too are driven by their profit maximization motive.

Another form of intervention is pressure from social groups which has been discussed earlier.

Lastly, international cooperation seems to be an effective option.

However, achieving international cooperation is extremely difficult because even though nations may have a common interest in preventing climate change, many are reluctant to act on it by reducing carbon emissions voluntarily.

The Paris Accords on Climate change is an effective global climate-deal, binding 195 countries to live up to the environmental standards set by it to protect the planet.

How many countries are actually abiding by it?

To conclude, the capitalist system does not provide incentives for protecting the environment.

Firms are constantly under threat and try to cut costs deliberately at the cost of the environment to maximize profit.

Hence, the environment gets exploited and degraded in a capitalist economy.

Without external non-market intervention such as the government, national and international watchdogs and social organizations, our planet will fall victim to the vicious cycle of capitalism, which includes environmental degradation.

 

The author is currently pursuing her Master of Development Studies from Brac University