American agronomist Craig Meisner reflects on four decades of life, work in Bangladesh

How did your interest in agriculture begin? 

When I was in high school, I saw the Concert for Bangladesh on TV, organized in the midst of their famine and war.  At that time, I had no idea about Bangladesh or East Pakistan. But it opened my eyes, and I realized that I didn’t have to simply get a job, that I could do something that would have an impact on the wider world. I decided that after high school, I would earn a degree that provided an “international business card”, so to speak.

In my senior year of high school, I decided math and organic chemistry would be my subjects in university. we were doing that classic experiment to synthesize caffeine from a cup of tea, where you are left with white crystal of caffeine two weeks later. But when I went to weigh the sample, I dropped it. I decided then and there that I didn’t want to be either a mathematician or a chemist!I took an Army Vocational Test, a series of weirdly disjointed questions that were supposed to indicate what vocation would be a good fit.  The test suggested I should be an outdoor, musical, agricultural scientist.And that’s basically what I ended up becoming!

What brought you to Bangladesh in the first place?

After I got my Master’s degree in International Agriculture, I looked for job that would take me abroad.  I tried the missionary route, but there were few positions in agriculture. So I went with my wife and new-born son to eastern North Carolina to teach agriculture at a community college. These are post-secondary institutions that offer two-year “Associate” degrees, for those who don’t want to spend four-years at university to get a Bachelor’s degree. It turned out to be an important experience for us. We learned that when you find yourself in an environment where there may be prejudice or racial intolerance toward others, one had to learn not to judge, but to understand, and not to justify, but to comprehend.  

This lesson stood us in very good stead, for in August 1980 we landed in Bangladesh for the first time. Three months of language instruction in Dhaka, and then it was off to Faridpur, to join the Christian Health and Agricultural Project, Alahdipur. CHAPA was a comprehensive village development project, run by the Presbyterian Church and Bangladesh Baptist Fellowship Church, in collaboration with the Bangladesh Government, with the goal of improving health, agriculture and adult literacy in rural areas.  Meanwhile, my wife went to work for a village adult literacy program, organized by what was at that time a small, little-known NGO called Brac.

What were your first impressions of this country, all those years ago?

The extreme poverty really hit you. But you have to quickly learn that you cannot solve it all. Instead, you do your own job,and add to the solution.  As Mother Teresa said, her work is but a drop in the ocean, but it is her drop to give.  Squatting toilets were new.  I’ll never forget a conversation with my driver as we were waiting for a ferry to cross the river from Dhaka to Faridpur. I asked him to describe how you use water and your left hand.  I recall I cringed a bit.  Then he asked me how we use toilet paper and our right hand, and he cringed even more!   Later I wrote an article titled “Don’t Let the Right Hand Know What the Left Hand is Doing”, reminding people to be tolerant and understanding of local practices. The article was widely read by missionaries throughout the world.

What was life like in Faridpur in those days? 

Life in Faridpur was hard at first. We had electric lines but electricity only for a few days a week.  We used a kerosene refrigerator, a kerosene burner and kerosene lamps. But we learned and adapted over time. We got to know a British agricultural missionary couple in Barisal, veterans of Bangladesh who had lived there for their entire lives. We would visit them and compare notes. We got used to having helpers at home. Our second son was born in Chittagong, and their ayah watched over our children while my wife and I went to work.  

At that time, we were the only foreigners we knew of in Faridpur. The village children used to call us “red monkeys”because we reminded them of the British, who would turn red in the sun! We didn’t take any offence; they meant no harm.  Everyone we have ever met in Bangladesh has treated us with nothing but respect.  We endeared ourselves to locals further after we learned to speak Bangla. Two of my three sons were born in the American Missionary Hospital in Chittagong, and they all have Bangla names: Ujol, Shanto and Shushamoi.

You were a friend and close associate of Norman Borlaug, the Nobel Prize winning scientist often called the father of the “Green Revolution”, and one of the most influential figures of the 20th century. Can you tell us a little about him, and about the work that you did together, in Mexico and later in Bangladesh?

I first got to know Norm at the International Maize and Wheat Improvement Center in Mexico. I would join him for dinner in the canteen, as he was always sitting alone.   I brought Norm to Bangladesh in the late 1990’s. His work in India, adding the dwarf gene to wheat and rice so that fertilized plants did not grow too tall and collapse from the weight of the grain, had drastically increased yields, and revolutionized agriculture there. I wanted him to come and see that his work had made a similar impact in Bangladesh, and to give people here a chance to meet him. He visited various places where Bangladeshis were doing agriculture research, including Bangladesh Agricultural University, where he received an honorary doctorate.  

What did you learn from Norman Borlaug?

Norm worked so very hard all his life. When the Nobel Prize Committee called one day in 1970 at four in the morning, his wife had to answer the phone because Norm had already left for work.When she finally found him in the field, and told him he had just won the Nobel Prize, he refused to believe it!Norm was equally demanding of others, and the work culture at CIMMYT really took a toll on family life. One day, in the Sheraton Hotel, where I would serve as his chaperone when he visited Dhaka, he confessed to me that not spending more time with his family was the biggest regret of his life. That was the most important lesson that I learned from him. So regardless of how hard I would work during the week, or how much I travelled, I always tried to spend weekends with my family. On the other hand, Norm’s work ethic was a trait I admired. So basically, my philosophy has been that the greatest satisfaction comes from finding the proper balance between work and family. 

What you have done or contributed with respect to your work here in Bangladesh that makes you proud?

In 1992, there were 3,000 hectares of maize planted in the country, all rain-fed and open pollinated (i.e. non-hybrid), yielding approximately 2,000 kilograms of maize per hectare.  I brought maize hybrids to Bangladesh,to be tested, reproduced, and released, by the Bangladesh Agricultural Research Institute (BARI) as well as private companies. Today there are approximately 300,000 hectares planted with maize,with seeds from a vibrant private sector, 100% irrigated and fertilized. Bangladesh now has the highest national maize yields in all of Asia, at approximately 8 tons per hectare. And still increasing.

And thirty years ago, you only found wheat grown in the Northeast of the country, where the winter weather was cooler. If someone had suggested growing wheat in Satkhira, I would have laughed!But today, after years of work at the Wheat Research Center to breed for heat tolerance and high yields,we now have flourishing wheat fields in Satkhira.

So you could say Bangladesh has gone from “basket-case”, as some derisively referred to it after Independence, to “bread basket”?

In some ways, Bangladesh has become a “rice basket”, having become self-sufficient in rice production for quite some years now.  For wheat, the growth in demand has been such that local production simply cannot meet it.  Three years ago, Bangladesh became the fourth largest importer of wheat in the world.

What other interventions or policies have had the biggest impact? 

Aquaculture is one. As Country Director for WorldFish, I saw firsthand that introducing people to aquaculture, in the proper way, literally sucks people out of poverty. The data showed it, time after time. And donors responded. At WorldFish I had a budget of $12 million a year and a team numbering one hundred and seventy, committed to this revolution. The results are now clearly visible to everyone. 

Another is simply teaching people to manage finances. A few years ago,WorldFish teamed up with the IRRI and CIMMYT to give selected villages the technology to harvest rice, wheat, maize, fish and shrimp.  One day we three Country Directors visited a village.  I asked the locals which technology had transformed their lives the most.  One man held up a book and said “accounting”. WorldFish had included a clear and detailed accounting module in our aquaculture training. This was a life changing moment for me. I realized that understanding expenses, revenue, and profits was the single most important step that farm families could take to make the transition from subsistence farmers to agricultural producers.

So one of your life-changing interventions actually had less to do with agriculture per se and more to do with what are often referred to as “life skills”?

Indeed. That was the moment I realized that technology has to be coupled with life skills, in order for people to fully benefit and take advantage of it. 

This is interesting, because one theory is that societies that adopted an agricultural way of life learned to value knowledge and technology, precisely because they needed to measure things, keep accounts, and so forth, and that this ultimately gave them a competitive advantage. Now agriculture is subject to new forces of innovation, based on capturing and analyzing “big data”. In your opinion,what are some promising applications of data-centric technologies for agriculture in Bangladesh?

We recently released the beta version of an app, called Kamari or Farm, that is being developed jointly by FAO, the Bangladesh Agriculture Research Council and various departments within the Government that have expertise in GIS technology. The app takes the geo-reference of the farm you are standing in, and links it to a Lidar Digital Elevation Model database that contains very precise record of elevations, for the entire country. The app will permit precise modeling for many agricultural tasks, such as coastal and flood plains management, drainage, proper fertilization, and so on. No other country in this part of the world has built such a database. This technology has the potential to revolutionize agriculture in Bangladesh, in both public and private sectors. 

On the other hand, innovation can lead to loss of livelihoods. New technologies often reward economies of scale, putting small producers at a disadvantage. Are you concerned for small farmers in Bangladesh in the new world of agriculture?

No. Small holdings have the freedom to diversify, compared to the large landholders.   It’s the farm diversification that we see in the domestic agricultural sector that drives the profitability of agriculture in Bangladesh - not large landholders.

You have obviously met and worked with many Bangladeshis in your time. Who are some that stand out, in your memory, for their dedication and contribution to the development of agriculture and food security in Bangladesh?  

My colleague, Dr Sufi Moinuddin Ahmed, comes to mind. I have always been inspired by his dedication and contribution. Sufi started in the 1960’s when there was very little wheat grown in Bangladesh. Wheat was rain-fed then, so drought tolerance was important. Now all the wheat grown in Bangladesh is 100% irrigated. Through his breeding efforts, wheat became a staple crop in the Northwest.  Sufi truly is the Father of Wheat in this country.

Another was Professor Ahmad Shamsul Islam at the Department of Botany at Dhaka University. He was a close friend of mine. He and his daughter, Zeba Seraj, have worked tirelessly on biotechnology. There are so many that I cannot list them all. Bangladesh is full of many dedicated agriculture scientists. Bangladeshis have love and respect for science, in general. That is one of the distinguishing features of this country.  

In recent decades, we have watched neighboring countries become successful global exporters of fruit, vegetables, and seafood. Bangladesh has the potential to do the same. In your opinion, what are the most promising items for domestic producers to develop for export markets?

Fish and shrimp are the highest potential market expansion of all.  We used to export raw leather (and still do).  And now there is a growing market for finished leather and even leather shoes.  But don’t forget the domestic markets!  Strawberries and dragon fruit are now commonly found, seasonally, in all village markets. Quite an accomplishment.

Let’s talk about that. Because I don’t remember seeing many strawberries, for instance, in Bangladesh only a decade or two ago. Now little children in slums ask for strawberry cake! What is going on?

Strawberries were not grown in Bangladesh due to a plant virus, until a researcher at Rajshahi University developed a virus resistance. Now you can find strawberries, in season, in every market. Dragon fruit was introduced here by the Bangladesh Agriculture Research Institute only seven years ago. Now you can also find them in almost every market, throughout the country.

I have seen this happen throughout my career.When I first arrived in Faridpur, I grew some beautiful carrots on a farm and took them to the market. I couldn’t give them away!  Now in every village, in every vegetable dish, or shingara, you find carrots.And tomatoes. Before Independence, nobody here ate tomatoes.  Broccoli was once found only in the upscale markets. Now you can find it everywhere.  The list goes on and on. This openness to new foods and changing diets is another distinguishing feature of Bangladesh; there is no other country in South Asia quite like this.

So what are some bottlenecks or challenges that domestic producers must overcome in order to find export markets for the many fruit and vegetables that are grown here?

Essentially, Bangladeshi agricultural exporters have to address the reputational issues created by some unscrupulous vegetable and fruit exports in the past. But it can be done. One way is through third-party certification and testing, before export.Another is to embrace traceability. If these practices are adopted, there is no reason why domestic vegetable and fruit producers cannot fully compete in the export markets. 

Let’s hope more entrepreneurs accept these challenges. But as you know, many young Bangladeshis dream of studying or living abroad, especially in the US and once they leave, many do not come back. What would you say to a young, ambitious Bangladeshi today, as they make important life decisions?

To a young ambitious Bangladeshi today, I would say: learn Chinese. Before Covid, the New York Times reported that there were 5 lakh Chinese nationals living, working, and investing in Bangladesh.  These Chinese expats need not only translators, but also able business partners here in this country.  The same is true for Koreans, who are moving their garment industry from Myanmar to Bangladesh. And then there is Japan, the largest development partner in Bangladesh. Knowledge and understanding of their language will also be valuable.

I often use Uber, and the drivers complain about the cut that Uber takes (most think, incorrectly, that this money ends up in the States). I always tell them: just wait. We already have Pathao and Obhai. A smart, software-savvy Bangladeshi entrepreneur will create a local business that will easily compete with Uber. Sooner than we think.

Now that you’re returning to the US, what will you miss most about Bangladesh?

The people, a society and culture that goes back thousands of years, and the food!I will miss the delicious Bangladeshi food: mutton curry, beef bhuna, bhorta, shrimp malay. And nothing compares to Khulna’s chewy jhal beef!

Bangladeshis are among the most generous people I have ever encountered.  I often hear that the USA is rich. Economically, that may be true.  But my homeland is a young country, whereas Bangladesh has such a rich history and culture.

Not long after we first arrived in Faridpur, my small family and I were invited to dinner by our project’s night guard,in his family’s one room hut. The dinner they had prepared for us had cost him the equivalent, based on his salary, of $200! That was the first of so many examples of the generosity I have experienced in my thirty-four years living and working in Bangladesh.

Craig, thank you for your time, and thank you for all you have done over the last four decades to improve the lives of people here in Bangladesh. 

You’re welcome. I leave with wonderful memories, and I will always look back upon my life and career in Bangladesh with great satisfaction.