OP-ED: The curious case of Sputnik V

Russia is having, as this newspaper reports, considerable problems in producing the Sputnik V vaccine. 

There is a global campaign to insist that all patents on all vaccines must be waived, invalidated even. 

The first point shows why the second is irrelevant to beating Covid-19. 

But then that is not what that second point is about anyway. Rather, there are still those out there who want to smash capitalism and yes, they will use any circumstance to do so.

As the report on the Russian problems goes there are significant difficulties in producing a vaccine. The new factory has to be constructed, the bioreactors tried out and then run in production runs. 

The staff have to be found and trained. It's necessary to assemble the supply chain – 150 different ingredients are not unusual in these new vaccines – and even then there is no guarantee that each reactor full of vaccine will actually be the correct stuff. 

And here is the thing – there are no patent problems here at all. 

This is a Russian developed vaccine, it is their own intellectual property.

The current difficulty with vaccines is making them, not the permission to make them. 

The entire issue of patents is entirely moot, or, as we can also say, nothing to do with it.

Yes, President Biden has just announced that America will waive all its patents if everyone else does too. What is going on here? 

Essentially, a political movement is using Covid-19 as an excuse. 

There are all too many people still infected with the Marxist idea of the labour theory of value. Something is worth the value of the labour that goes into its production. 

If we have something that already exists – an idea, a patent, a book, a piece of software even – then the price of that should be the labour to make the next piece of it, the cost of copying. 

Knowledge should not be a possession is the same idea in another guise.

The problem with this is that however pure it is as a theoretical idea it simply does not work. 

For who will invest to make that first piece, or knowledge, to be copied if there can be no fee from the second, third and millionth? 

In fact, standard economics agrees that in theory patents and copyrights are not a good idea except if we want a world that works – this is a second-best world and so there will be solutions that are less than perfect.  

This is the battle that is actually being fought, using Covid-19 as an excuse. 

If the political activists can convince that, in these special circumstances, drug patents should be violated then it becomes much easier to make the same argument again and again. 

Until there is their desired world in which there is no intellectual property – and therefore no one creates anything new that can be copied.

What our report from Russia tells us is that this is an argument being used in bad faith. 

The problem is not patents. 

As in Russia, it is the knowledge of how to actually do it. 

The embedded, local, knowledge of how to make the process work – not the permission on paper to use the process. 

There are no western pharmaceutical companies with patents on the Sputnik vaccine. 

The Sputnik vaccine is having production problems. Therefore it cannot be pharmaceutical patents causing the production problems. 

Making all Covid-19 vaccine patents free to everyone won't increase the production of vaccines by one single dose nor bring forward the production by one single day. 

So, why all the arguments that it must be done? Some people just do not like capitalism and will use any excuse to try to kill it off. 

Yes, they will even try to use a global pandemic.

Pretty sick behaviour really and far, far worse than the accusations being thrown at the capitalists and pharmaceutical companies. 

For the reality is that at the moment anyone who asks to be allowed to use one of these patents is allowed to do so. 

There are hundreds of licences already written and out there. 

It is not just that killing the patents won't help any way they are already free to use for the duration of the crisis anyway.

It is just astonishing that people are putting so much effort into this battle against patents when it is entirely and wholly irrelevant – unless you want to play politics that is.

 

Tim Worstall is a senior fellow at the Adam Smith Institute in London