OP-ED: Sticking to the rule of law

A little tale from the old India, when the British were still in Bengal. 

A junior officer met his early end and was buried under a gravestone that read “He always kept his word.” 

Bernard Weatherill was, much more recently, the Speaker of the House of Commons and he said that that is what he would like on his headstone. 

Bernard Levin, who was the greatest, by far, British journalist of his generation used to use exactly this as an example of the life rightly lived. 

Would you like that to be how you are recalled, or prefer “He always acted for the best”?

There is a point to this little bit of historical trivia, for it speaks directly to Adam Smith's injunction of how to make a place rich. 

That move from barbaric penury to civilised opulence requires but “peace, easy taxes and the tolerable administration of justice”. 

It is that last of the trio that the historical tale illustrates. 

For justice requires that the law be known, that it be stable, that what we're judged under is what the law was when we did whatever was alleged. 

Sure, it can be that our rulers, the government, realise that they have made a mistake, that the law needs to be changed. 

But we can only be guilty of the new offence if we do it after they have changed the law – no real freedom can be had if they can newly make illegal what we have already done.

This applies as much to business and taxation law as it does to anything more personal. 

It is terribly easy for those governors to bend the law to deal with a specific problem. 

The damage that does being that they are no longer acting according to their word. And if we could not trust them last time then why would we do so next? 

Or, as actually happens, if an investment is not safe because they've changed the law on it then who would make the next investment? 

This being the mistake India is making in its commercial relationships at the moment. 

It is, of course, always amusing to make fun of the neighbours when they are making a mistake but the important thing is to recognise that mistake and not make it ourselves. 

India is changing commercial law according to what they perceive are their best short-term interests and in doing so tearing up their word, what they said they would do. 

This is going to significantly reduce future foreign investment in the Indian economy. 

And the one thing India does need is that foreign investment – there is, after all, no shortage of people or skill or ideas or entrepreneurship there.

The evidence of this is not exactly in short supply. 

Vodafone bought the Indian operations of Hutchison. The Indian government wanted the capital gains tax. 

Under Indian law, if the seller does not pay it then the buyer should. 

Well, okay, that was in the law before the transaction. 

It might be a silly law, a bad one even, but it was what the law was. 

But the transaction was actually between two companies in Mauritius. 

So, the claim was that tax was not payable. This was argued through the courts and eventually the Supreme Court said that Vodafone was right, the government wrong, no tax was payable.

In a country with the rule of law then that is that, right? 

But if we are going to do what is best, or what seems best at the time, that is not. India then changed the law retroactively. That is, changed the law many years after the events had happened. 

This is not likely to make foreigners invest in the future now, is it? Oh, and India lost at arbitration as well.

The second case was Cairn Energy. They listed local operations in India and – seven years later – were hit with a retroactive tax demand. 

Cairn has won at every level of the legal system so far but the Indian government simply will not give in and agree, well, that is what the law was at that time. 

And if you cannot be sure of what is written in the law books then you cannot be sure of the safety or security of your investments, can you?

The third case is, to my mind, even more outrageous. 

A company called Devas Multimedia signed an agreement in 2005 with the commercial arm of the state space monopoly, Antrix, to build out satellite and terrestrial communications services across India. 

The plan would have seen Devas build and then lease two communications satellites on the S-band spectrum managed by the Indian Space Research Organisation (ISRO) for multimedia services. 

Then in 2011, the government first delayed the project repeatedly and then ripped up the agreement. 

Well, that is bad enough, but it gets worse. Devas has won at every round of arbitration – this is going to a court not controlled by the government you are suing, as laid out in the contract that Antrix signed and in Treaties to which the Indian government is a signatory.  

The company obtained a $1.2 billion arbitral award it is seeking to enforce.

At which point the government, in broad daylight, seized control of the company, fired its counsel, appointed a liquidator and is now arguing that its own appointee should now drop all this legal stuff and act as if the arbitral award never happened and.....well, this is not even the tolerable administration of justice, is it? 

Entirely it is not the tolerable anything. It is not keeping one's word in the slightest, it is bending and changing the law according to what seems most convenient at any one moment.

The danger of this is that it simply diminishes anyone's confidence in investment. Not just foreigners in fact – if you cannot be sure of the law then why would you, as a citizen of a place, bother to invest? Or at least invest legally rather than in the informal economy? 

The damage, in the long term, from this will be far greater than any tax lost in the first two cases, or damages that must be paid in the third.

We, in Bangladesh, have the advantage of being able to see this being done and therefore have an example of what not to do. Adam Smith was actually right, the rule of law is a necessary precondition for economic development. 

So, we can change it for the future, if we wish, but we have got to stick to the rules that are already in place at any one time. 

For in government policy and actions “He always acted for the best” is something that brings that gravestone for the economy rather closer – keeping one's word does work better.


The author is a Senior Fellow at the Adam Smith Institute in London.