The definition of genius is taking the complex and making it simple, the great physicist Albert Einstein once said.
And it is this saying that Tanvir Ahmed Mishuk made his mantra when it came to steering Nagad, the digital financial services company that inadvertently came into being during a brainstorming session with his childhood friend Nahim Razzaq on one frigid evening in London in 2015.
The two were preparing their respective speeches the following morning at the two-day UK-Bangladesh e-Commerce Fair organised by the ICT Division, Bangladesh Hi-Tech Park Authority and Computer Jagat.
It was then the two realised that without a fuss-free payments solution and efficient logistics, e-commerce would not really take off in Bangladesh.
This was included in Mishuk’s speech, which piqued the attention of Tarana Halim, then the state minister for Posts and Telecommunication.
“She called us and said, ‘Look, we have both payment service and logistics in the post office. Why don’t you digitalise it?’” Mishuk told Dhaka Tribune yesterday, on the eve of Nagad’s second anniversary.
This set off him on a path that has gone on to liven up the mobile financial services arena in Bangladesh.
“We studied the market. There were 30 MFS licences then and yet, 70 per cent of the population were outside of the financial umbrella. Clearly, there is a market to cater to but why was no one succeeding?”
What Mishuk figured was the cumbersome account-opening procedure that was putting off people from getting one.
The account-opening form was two pages long and it took 7-10 days.
He wanted to streamline the process and inspiration struck from his frequent business trips to Singapore. “There, for everything you need the IC [Identity Card]”
“We were the first to introduce digital KYC in Bangladesh. We ask the customer to provide a photo of their national identity card and a selfie and the account is opened in less than a minute.”
Nagad’s system, which is built by local engineers on the backbone provided by South Korean KONA I, pulled information from the national identity card database and checked if the selfie was a 70 per cent match with the one on the Election Commission’s record.
The exercise initially took five minutes but has now been brought down to ten seconds.
“The Bangladesh Bank did not have a guideline for this and the other regulators and competitors objected to it, saying it would increase terrorist financing and money laundering,” says the 39-year-old serial entrepreneur.
But Mustafa Jabbar, the telecom minister, was a staunch supporter of Mishuk’s methods.
“He said he would shut down Nagad if anyone could prove that the digital KYC would increase money laundering or terrorist financing.”
But none could.
“Following us, the Bangladesh Bank made the e-KYC guideline.”
But, Mishuk was still not satisfied.
“Only 30 per cent of the people have smartphones and the easy client onboarding process would only work for those. What about those with bar phones? They were the majority. We needed to get on board just as easily.”
This led to another innovation: one can open a Nagad account by simply dialling *167# and setting a personal identification number.
Nagad’s system then pulls the information of the customer from the mobile operators’ database, which already has subscribers’ NID, by way of an agreement it had signed.
Another innovation that the operator brought to the market is the option of sending money to any mobile number, and one which was, once again, inspired by Mishuk’s time in Singapore.
“You don’t need to have an active Nagad account to be able to receive money. Money can be sent to your mobile number and once you open a Nagad account the amount will automatically show in your balance.”
After successful piloting of the project in 2017, the ministry of posts, telecommunications and information technology floated a tender for the full-fledged operation of the Post Office’s DFS service in 2018.
“You would be surprised to learn that all mobile operators participated in the tender and many others. Mobile operators cannot get an MFS licence from the Bangladesh Bank, so they were hoping to get one from the Post Office. But we won because we did the pilot.”
And so began Nagad’s journey in full swing on March 26, 2019 -- much to the resentment of the existing mobile financial services players then.
As per the Post Office Act 1898, a Nagad user could transact a total of Tk 2.5 lakh per day whereas it was Tk 30,000 for the other MFS providers.
Each transaction, of which 10 were allowed, could be up to Tk 50,000. But for the other MFS providers, the cash-in limit was Tk 15,000 and cash-out Tk 10,000 a day.
The monthly transaction limit for Nagad customers was Tk 5 lakh, whereas for the others operating under the BB’s regulations it ranged from Tk 25,000 to Tk 1 lakh.
This meant Nagad made a flying start, leapfrogging Dutch-Bangla Bank’s Rocket to become the number two player in the market with a 30 per cent share of the market.
But its flight hit turbulence on March 5 last year, when the central bank asked banks to suspend the trust-cum-settlement accounts of companies that were providing MFS and digital wallet services without its approval.
Nagad was the only MFS provider running without the BB’s approval then.
Several banks froze Nagad’s accounts, making it difficult for the company to run its operations.
This compelled the company to seek out a full-fledged licence from the BB.
In April last year, the central bank gave Nagad a temporary licence for six months.
During the period, the operator had to fulfil the central bank’s laundry list of requirements before it became eligible for the full licence.
And one of the terms were bringing down the additional transaction limit it enjoyed that allowed it to gain a huge customer base soon after rolling out services.
But the big condition, which Nagad is yet to fulfil, is forming a separate entity clearly outlining the stakes of each party.
At present, Nagad is being run as a joint venture between Third Wave Technologies and the Bangladesh Post Office.
It was until June 30 to do so.
And once it does, a world of opportunities await.
“My aim is to set up a digital bank and roll out a superapp like the ones you have in China.”
A digital bank is where retail banking services would be delivered through the internet or other forms of electronic channels instead of physical branches.
And for the digital bank to happen for Nagad, a full-fledged MFS licence from the BB is necessary.
“Digital bank is what the country needs. To bring down the charges to Tk 1-2 from the existing rates, a digital bank is needed.”
Nagad has done the backend work.
“If we get the licence we can get the digital bank running in three months.”
The engine for the digital bank came from KONA I but the rest of the work has been done by our in-house, homegrown engineers.
“I want to bring in all the money from the informal economy. There are still too many people keeping their money under the pillow. If those come under the formal financial channel, the GDP growth can be 12-13 per cent.”
Mishuk strives to bring 80 per cent of the population under the financial umbrella by way of his trailblazing company, which has also whipped up a price war in the MFS industry.
Until last year, the charge for withdrawing cash from the mobile financial services platform, introduced in 2011, was Tk 18.5 for every Tk 1,000.
That changed when Nagad brought down the charge to Tk 11.49 and also made sending money to other accounts on their network through the mobile app free of charge.
The move also appears to have ignited a much-needed price war of sorts in the industry of 16 players, where the rates have stayed the same since the platform’s initiation nearly a decade ago.
Earlier this month, bKash announced it was making sending money within its network free of charge to five numbers.
Once the transactions to the five numbers hit Tk 25,000 in a month, a Tk 5 charge would be applicable in the subsequent transactions. When the transactions hit Tk 50,000 in the month, a Tk 10 charge is applicable on the following transactions.
Typically, when a service gets the scale, the charges come down, which is what happened with mobile phone service and broadband internet -- the two industries where the rates have come down exponentially, thanks in part to the proactive nature of the regulator.
In December last year, the average daily transactions through the MFS operators stood at Tk 1,824.4 crore. Five years earlier, it was Tk 773.8 crore, according to data from the Bangladesh Bank.
After fixing the rates ten years ago, the banking regulator has not revised them once.
As per that guideline, a cash-out charge of Tk 20 for every Tk 1,000 is allowed.
Had the BB ran a fresh cost modelling process, the charges would have invariably come down, making the platform more affordable for the marginal people, who tend to remain out of the banking umbrella.
“We are a nation where 10 per cent of the population still cannot even afford bar phones, so a charge of Tk 20 for every Tk 1,000 is excessive,” Mishuk said.
He also thinks the BB’s proposed interoperability between MFS players will not work if the fees are excessive.
“If interoperability is not free, it will be a failure. This is such a huge market that five players can thrive.”