Recycling poses two problems. The first is the issue of resources themselves, the very reason that we aim to do recycling.
Better to take what we have already extracted from the Earth and run it through the system again rather than dig up new material and throw away the old.
Well, sometimes we use fewer total resources starting all over again than we do by trying to recycle. But let us assume that we are recycling things that make sense to recycle.
As this newspaper reports, this includes PET bottles. Yes, they are made of that great horror, plastic, but they can be entirely recycled into more PET bottles. So, we probably should do so.
The second problem though is more purely economic. How, exactly, do we collect whatever it is that we are trying to recycle? The problem is that recycling is economics work the opposite way from the more normal world.
We are all aware of how things in bulk are lower priced than things that are small and useful packages.
Each kilo of rice on a ship full of 50,000 tonnes of rice is a lower price than when it arrives, in useful portions of one kilo each, to sit in our kitchen. This is obvious and logical.
People must transport it from the ship and repackage it. Then it goes on trucks and through shops, and so on.
But more crucially, that 1 kg is more useful to us and thus more valuable when it is right by our stove, ready for use than 200 km away on that ship in Chittagong.
We are entirely used to this; things are more valuable when in smaller packages and distributed. Recycling works exactly the opposite way.
Sure, the metals in a mobile phone are valuable. Or at least can be. But one single mobile phone in the middle of Sylhet is of very little value if our recycling plant is in Jessore.
For we have to get that phone to the recycling plant, an activity that consumes resources. 10 phones in Sylhet are each worth more just because there are now 10 phones in a pile to be taken to Jessore. And 100 more again, and so on.
Partly, this is because of those transport costs, just as with the rice but working the other way around.
But it is also true that at the recycling plant, one phone is worth near nothing. Because there are economies of scale -- to crush the phone, run it through acid perhaps, to run the factory extracting the metals, it is not worth doing this on one phone.
The distribution of the things we consume means that they increase in value as they disperse through the country to where they are going to be used. Recycling works exactly the other way around.
The value of each item increases as it becomes an ever-smaller part of an ever-larger pile.
10 kg of iron scrap is worth just about nothing. 1,000 tonnes of iron scrap is excellent and valuable input for a steel plant. Thus, the value of the 10 kg, when part of the 1,000 tonnes, is higher than when the 10 kg is on its own.
This all sounds a little odd, perhaps too much detail even, but it is crucial when we consider recycling.
It is vital that we think about the question: how to collect all that material from where it is individually, and thus worth near-nothing, and bring it to that great big pile by the recycling factory where it is worth something?
Here we meet the usual economic answer to near all questions: it depends. It depends upon exactly what it is that we are talking about, the specifics of the individual item itself.
With plastic bottles, like with these PET ones, the value of each bottle is too low for anyone to worry about collecting it.
Even though it makes sense, when we have that pile of tonnes of them to recycle, it is the cost of getting them into the pile that kills the process.
At which point we need to change the value of each bottle so that it has a value which is sufficient to encourage people to collect and deliver them.
We do this by applying a deposit to the bottle when it is made or imported. Some small sum that will not change the decision to purchase in the first place. But enough -- just enough -- to encourage people to collect and deliver them. Quite how much this is will depend upon the time and place.
In California (and about the same in Germany too) that deposit might be 10 cents. That's enough for people to think that 10 makes a dollar and, well, a dollar is a dollar.
It is not going to make Bill Gates or Jeff Bezos worry about reclaiming the deposit. But it is enough that some people will go out to collect them.
How much is enough to do this in Bangladesh? You will know better but that's the correct thing to be thinking about.
If the deposit was just Tk 1, would that make people collect them? If collecting 10 or 30 bottles means the same earnings as a short rickshaw ride then probably, yes. Or maybe it should be Tk 2.
But there is some number that is enough to get people making money by collecting and delivering to the recycling plant.
So, that's what we should do. The economic problem with recycling is how do we go about collecting what it is that we want to recycle.
The answer is that we impose a deposit upon the item so that people earn money by collecting and delivering it. And here is the thing. No recycling system will be successful without coming up with a solution to this problem.
Tim Worstall is a senior fellow at the Adam Smith Institute in London