Faulty pricing formula: Smokers pay higher than tag prices

Cigarette consumers are paying disproportionately high prices at retail level, thanks to faulty pricing formula of the revenue board.

Smokers of low- segment cigarettes are bearing the brunt of the flawed pricing rule, while the exchequer deprives of an estimated revenue earnings of Tk1,700 crore per annum, industry sources have said.

The proposed budget has increased the price for per stick of low-segment cigarette by only Tk0.20, but the retailers are charging as high as Tk1 more for each stick under the category.

Currently, around 15 low- segment cigarette brands are being marketed in the country that account for roughly 72% of the total yearly cigarette consumption, according to the National Board of Revenue (NBR) data.

The number of cigarette sticks consumed in a year is estimated at 7,000 crore.

The government in the proposed budget for the next fiscal year has increased the price of Low-segment cigarette packet (10-sticks) from Tk37 to Tk39, High segment  from Tk93 to Tk97 and Premium segment from Tk123 to Tk 128.

The prices include 81% tax for Medium (Star, NAVY), High (Gold Leaf) and Premium (Benson& Hedges) segment cigarettes, while a 73% tax incidence is applicable to low segment cigarettes.

The price for low segment cigarettes in the current budget for the current 2019-20 financial year was hiked only by 5.71%, while a staggering 31.25% for medium segment  cigarettes.

“Due to the abnormal price hike consumers of medium segment cigarettes switched to low segment ones. On the other hand, insignificant price hike helped low brand cigarettes to expand their market share overnight at the cost of huge revenue for the government,” a senior official of a multinational cigarette company told Dhaka Tribune.

“We met several times with the NBR authorities and briefed them on how revenue earnings could be enhanced through regulatory interventions without hurting consumers’ wallets.”

Talked, Masud Sadik, Member (Vat Policy), NBR said the price adjustment made in the proposed budget did not rest solely on the revenue board, as budget involved other higher authorities also.

On higher prices being charged by retailers, wholesalers and distributors, he said the price monitoring must be conducted by the commerce ministry, not by the revenue board.

It was, however, learnt that the NBR in the proposed budget had suggested the finance ministry to hike the price of lower segment cigarette from Tk37 to Tk41 for the grounds of earning more revenue and discouraging people to consume low quality cigarettes on health ground.

“But, our proposal was not approved, as a powerful group of local low quality cigarette manufacturers influenced the government,” a top NBR official, preferring anonymity, told Dhaka Tribune. 

On the other hand, it was alleged from the cigarette industry that NBR had been favouring low segment  cigarette companies for their own interests, ignoring the interests of consumers and government’s revenue.

Visiting markets yesterday, it was found that prices of most of the low segment cigarettes were being sold 25% to 26% higher than prices during pre-budget time, although the draft budget proposed only a 5.40% price hike on low segment cigarettes.

Take for an instance, a stick of Derby cigarette which used to be sold at Tk4 before the proposed budget, now sells at Tk5. Similar price hike was also found for brands like Royal, Pilot and Hollywood.

While no price hike has taken place for Star and Navy in the market, prices of per stick Benson & Hedges and Gold leaf increased by Tk1.

As per the pricing of the NBR, a stick of low quality cigarettes is supposed to be sold at Tk3.90.

Masud Sadik said the retailers could not charge more than Tk3.90 for a stick of low brand cigarette.

“It is illegal to sell more than tagged prices,” Masud said.

However, retailers, wholesalers and distributors argued that ‘Paisa’ transaction no longer exists in the market. They blamed the faulty pricing formula that had led retailers and wholesalers to charge higher prices to customers without any revenue benefit for the government.

Shariful Hasan, a cigarette wholesaler at Mohammadpur says, if the price of low segment cigarette stick was fixed at between Tk4.3 and Tk4.5 by the NBR, retailers would sell at Tk5. But, the retailers could not sell a stick of cigarette for a profit of only Tk0.10, he added.

“It is a simple math. The government is deprived of huge revenue and consumers are forced to pay higher for the faulty pricing formula,” Shariful, a retired Assistant General Manager at Sonali Bank, said.

He said people are largely switching to low quality cigarettes, taking advantage of low prices that poses a serious health concern under the coronavirus situation.

Talked, a retailer at Kakrail says, a 10-stick packet of low segment cigarette he purchased at Tk78 (Tagged price is Tk74) from wholesale market and sold the packet at Tk95.

 “Profit is good now,” Sohel, the retailer said.

A cigarette wholesaler at Karwan Bazar said they could not sell at tagged prices, as distributors charged higher than tagged prices.

MD Iqbal Hossain, Sales Supervisor, Agrani Trading Corporation, which distributes cigarettes of British American Tobacco (BAT) for greater Dhaka region, says they do not charge higher prices.

He, however, says only sales Manager can clarify the issue well.

Anisur Rahman, Sales Manager, says he is not aware of any price hike as he has been under home quarantine.

Asked, Sheikh Shabab Ahmed, Head of External Affairs, BAT, said he had been busy.

The price distortion between low and medium segments started from 2018-2019 fiscal year brought down the share of cigarette market for medium segment brands from 50% to less than 20% as of May, this year.

Tobacco contributes over 10% of NBR revenue, NBR data says.

Medium segment smokers downgraded to low segment causing a massive net loss of revenue. The segment contributes around 40% of the tobacco tax revenue.

However, sales of medium segment cigarettes reduced by 60%, due to the faulty pricing formula of the government, sources alleged.

The price difference per stick between medium segment used to be Tk1 and now it is Tk3 per stick

The cigarette industry generated close to Tk 28,000 crore in FY 2018-2019, with a growth of about 25% over last year. It contributes roughly 10% of NBR revenue, according to data of NBR.