Multinational stocks dominate DSE's EPS chart

Multinational Companies (MNCs) now have the highest earnings per share (EPS) of the listed firms at the Dhaka Stock Exchange (DSE), due to good corporate governance practices.

Among the top 10 companies with the highest EPS, seven are MNCs, according to DSE data.

Additionally, MNCs also contributed the highest amount to market capitalization at the prime bourse. There are a total of 11 multinational companies at the DSE—whose market capitalization accounts for approximately 26%—out of around 300 listed companies.

These companies are: British American Tobacco (BAT) Bangladesh, Bata Shoe Company (Bangladesh), Reckitt Benckiser (BD), Linde Bangladesh Limited, GlaxoSmithKline (GSK), Marico Bangladesh, Renata Ltd, Berger Paints Bangladesh, Eastern Lubricants, and Meghna Petroleum Ltd.

Stock market analysts and stock brokers attributed this high performance of MNCs to management efficiency, business strategy, good corporate governance and ethical standards, and transparency in financial statements.

Speaking to the Dhaka Tribune, Ahmed Rashid Lali, former president of DSE Brokers Association (DBA), said: “Accounts of multinational companies are more transparent. Their governance systems and ethical standards are also very strong, which is rarely seen in local companies.”

Lali added that local companies sometimes have dubious investments, from which management pulls out money. "This is absent in MNCs, which is another reason for better earnings."

The highest EPS registered in 2017 was that of British American Tobacco Bangladesh. The Company has reported EPS of Tk. 130.50 for the year ending December 31, 2017, as against Tk. 126.37 for the previous year.

In the latest 3rd quarter (January-September’18) the company also reported (Un-audited) EPS of  Tk. 131.18.

Bata Shoe Company’s (Bangladesh) EPS was Tk. 82.34 for the year ending December 31, 2017, as against Tk. 76.24, for the same period in the previous year. The company’s EPS was Tk. 15.09 for July-September, 2018, as against Tk. 17.42 for July-September, 2017.

Reckitt Benckiser’s EPS was Tk. 80.63 for the year ending December 31, 2017. Its EPS was Tk. 22.51 for July-September 2018, and Tk. 41.88 for January-September 2018. Linde Bangladesh Limited EPS was k. 65.96 for the year ending December 31, 2018.

MNCs echo analysts' opinions

In its latest annual report, Bata Shoe Company Chairman Rajeev Gopalakrishnan said Bata Bangladesh has always played a leading role in innovating and transforming itself to prove its leadership in the footwear industry.

"To gain this objective, our company continued investing in technology, customer service, products, and other resources to cater to our customers' changing  lifestyles," he explained, adding that another objective is to ensure careful utilization of the company’s liquid resources.

Furthermore, dividend payouts to shareholders, cost advantage of future raw material purchases, and accumulation of resources for future investment to meet demand and to counter competition, also helped Bata succeed.

"The Board is satisfied that there are no short or long-term financial constraints at the close of the period," the report reads.

Golam Mainuddin, chairman of  BAT Bangladesh told the company's shareholders: “We believe that enriched corporate governance contributes to the long-term success of a company and creates trust and engagement between  the company and its stakeholders.” 

He added that the board of directors and management are committed to continuously striving  for the highest ethical standards to ensure that the business and its affairs are in strict adherence to integrity, transparency, and accountability to safeguard the interests of shareholders and stakeholders.

Chairman of Berger Paints Bangladesh Gerald K Adams, said in the company's latest annual report: “Berger is closely watching trends and developments in each of the risk areas, and takes the best possible measures to mitigate them through product and market diversification, efficient sourcing of materials, use of latest technology, and investment in research and development to gain sustained competitive advantage.”

Why do MNCs earn more and offer better dividends?

Foreign companies always attract the attention of investors and help keep the capital market stable.

Shakil Rizvi, president of DBA, said that the operational capacity and management efficiency level is lower in local companies than MNCs. "MNC officials are highly efficient and get paid more.

"Local companies must be made aware of the benefits of good governance," added Rizvi, a former president of DSE.

Since MNCs have a good track record in offering dividends, investors also prefer them over local companies.

Mozibur Rahman, a retired government official and stock market investor, said he invests in MNCs because they offer moderate income without high "risk of losing capital."

"Foreign companies are more transparent in disclosing financial statements and follow international standards. That is why they have consistent growth," he added.

Ensuring transparency

To bring transparency to a company’s financial statements, the authorities concerned have to make the chief financial officer (CFO) and the audit firms accountable, said one stock broker.

"Often, the CFO makes the financial statements as desired by the chairman or managing director of the company," he said, wishing to remain anonymous.

He added that the stock market regulator has to investigate, immediately punish, and bring changes to the companies' boards if they find them to be lacking good governance.

Former adviser to the caretaker government, Mirza Azizul Islam, said the Bangladesh Securities and Exchange Commission (BSEC) has devised steps to stop account manipulation.

"The Financial Reporting Act 2015 should be used to ensure good governance,” Mirza suggested, adding that family ownership of a company is a "threat to good governance," as sometimes the relatives of owners become independent directors.

"Independent directors are thought to be protectors of common investor interests," he added, explaining that this gives rise to a conflict of interest.

However, there are a few local companies in the capital market who are doing better because of good governance.

"To build investor confidence, the stock market regulator should focus on full-fledged implementation of regulations so that no company can falsify financial statements," said investor Mozibur.