It was Adam Smith who told us that there’s nothing more ridiculous than worrying about the balance of trade.
And since all of economics is either a footnote to Smith or wrong we should probably take note of his point.
Which means that some of the worrying about Bangladesh’s trade balance is misplaced.
Yes, it’s true, the current account deficit is up, some $754m in the July-January period as opposed to the surplus in the same period last year of $2.47bn.
But as Smith said this is nothing to worry about – the important thing we need to grasp is why we should not, in point of fact, worry about it.
The first reason is an over-arching theoretical one – why is it that we partake in trade at all? It is to gain access to those lovely imports that foreigners make better than we do. To think otherwise, to think that it is exports which make us richer is to fall into the pernicious trap of mercantilism.
I export my labour from my household, most certainly I do, and in return I get lovely money. But that money is not what improves my lifestyle – what I buy with it – that food and clothing and machinery which are the imports into my household – are what make my life better.
Thus imports are the reason that we trade, exports being just the hard work we’ve got to do to be able to afford them.
We can make the same point another way.
It’s entirely possible that we don’t divide and specialise labour at all. Many Bangladeshis live this way right now out in the country, or used to until very recently.
Pretty much everything the household consumed would be produced by that household. We have another name for those people too – the absolutely poor.
Once we do divide and specialise our labour then we must trade the resultant production. We export our own production not because we gain some heartfelt pleasure from seeing other people consuming what we have sweated blood and tears over, but because we are then able to import those things that others have worked to produce.
It is often a mistake to equate an economy to a household, certainly it is on such things as borrowing, currency and so on.
But on trade they are indeed conceptually equal, there’s no difference at all between household trade, regional trade and trade across national boundaries.
All of them make us richer as we gain access to those imports of what others make better than we do.
So, one way of looking at a trade deficit is that we’re getting richer, we’re gaining access to more imports, the very thing we conduct trade for in the first place.
The second point is a more detailed one about how trade statistics are done. We rather like the idea of foreigners putting their capital into Bangladesh in order to aid in developing industry and the country. We’re well aware that this also makes us richer, drives up local wages.
But we must recall that the balance of payments does balance, always and everywhere. This is not arguable, it is a definition.
We have the balance of trade in goods, then we add the balance in services – remittances are really a service export so we’re positive there – and that gives us the balance of trade, the very thing which Smith told us not to worry about.
That’s also, with minor adjustments, the current account.
The capital account, instead of it being foreigners sending us money for things we have made and sent them, is foreigners sending us money to make things which stay in Bangladesh. Foreign money to build a building, make a power station, construct a factory
And the balance of payments is the current account plus the capital account.
The capital account will always, and everywhere, be the inverse of the balance on the current. For, as I have said, the balance of payments always balances.
So what happens when someone decides to build a factory in an export zone, just as an example? We know that this will provide well paying jobs for Bangladeshis, well paid relative to the local alternatives that is, those jobs making people richer.
We generally regard this as a good thing, therefore, this sort of foreign direct investment. But that means, inevitably, that we will have a surplus on that capital account.
And as the BoP does always balance that means that we must have a deficit on the current account at the same time.
It’s entirely possible for us to say that we want to have a balanced current account. But that also means that we must develop the country only with the capital that we have, we cannot allow foreigners to send more in.
Equally, we can welcome with open arms that foreign capital, but that does mean that we’ll have to run trade deficits of some size.
What we cannot do is employ foreigners’ money to make us richer and also have a trade surplus. This is not arguable, this is definitional.
So, what is it that everyone would prefer? Get richer or do that ridiculous thing of worrying about the balance of trade? l
Tim Worstall is a Senior Fellow at the Adam Smith Institute in London.